Shoreline development risks accelerating habitat loss, loss of at-risk animal, bird and fish species, shoreline erosion and water quality decline.  These impacts will extend beyond the Bird River into Lac du Bonnet and the Winnipeg River system.

At least two protected species call the Bird River home: the Whip-poor-will and the Carmine Shiner. In fact, the Bird River is one of the only places where the Carmine Shiner can be found.  Further loss of habitat can only lead to a greater reduction in numbers of already endangered species. 

The Bird River already faces dangerous congestion; its narrow, shallow channels average a depth of only 15 feet, leaving little room for safe navigation when crowded with motorboats, swimmers, kayakers and other users, creating unsafe conditions for all.  Allowing more docks and launches create pinch points on an already narrow body of water that can endanger swimmers and increase traffic, accidents and conflicts on the water.  Modern cottages often support multiple vessels such as pontoon boats, speedboats, and personal watercraft, multiplying the stress on the river and its banks.

The claim made by the creators of the Winnipeg River Development Plan that rising boat numbers prove the moratorium has “failed” is deeply flawed - in reality, the moratorium has been effective in preventing even greater overcrowding.  Further, the proposed Vessel Operation Restriction Regulation (VORR) will not substantially limit boat traffic as the Planning District claims; it only restricts wake surfing and does nothing to reduce the overall number of vessels on the river.

Roads, highways, the 315 bridge and emergency services are already under pressure.  More development would add costs and further compromise safety and emergency response times.

The Bird River is treasured for its natural beauty, recreation, and ecological importance. Short-term development gains will permanently diminish its appeal for residents and visitors alike, and damage or eliminate the natural habitat of dozens of species of fish and wildlife.